Learning from Gatling Guns, Fighter Pilots, and Rockets:

Imagine a software company rolling out a new app. They meticulously plan, design, and code, pouring months of effort into a perfect launch. But when they finally release it, users are frustrated by a clunky interface and missing features. The company scrambles to fix the issues, but the damage is done. Negative reviews pile up, and users abandon the app. What went wrong? They forgot a crucial ingredient: the power of feedback and rapid iteration.

This isn't just a hypothetical scenario. It's a common pitfall. Companies invest heavily in upfront planning but neglect the iterative process of learning and improvement that comes from real-world use and customer feedback. To understand how to avoid this trap, let's draw inspiration from three sources: the Gatling gun, the Top Gun fighter pilot program, and SpaceX's rocket engines. These examples share a common thread – the power of feedback, coupled with rapid iteration, in driving innovation and achieving breakthrough results.

Feedback and rapid iteration enabled breakthrough performance throughout history

Mass-produced out of necessity and provided with constant feedback, the Gatling gun revolutionized warfare.

The Gatling gun, one of the first successful machine guns, offers a compelling example of how real-world testing and rapid iteration drive innovation. Early versions of the weapon were complex and prone to jamming. However, its widespread use in the American Civil War provided inventor Richard Gatling with invaluable feedback. Soldiers' experiences on the battlefield highlighted the gun's weaknesses, prompting Gatling to iterate on his design. He simplified the mechanism, improved reliability, and ultimately created a weapon that revolutionized warfare. (Hallahan, 2017) Gatling's success was intrinsically tied to his ability to quickly incorporate feedback, modify his designs, and shorten the time between iterations, ultimately accelerating the gun's development.

The Top Gun program gives fighter pilots access to experience in volume in a safe space.  

In the 1960s, the US Navy faced a crisis. Their fighter pilots were losing dogfights at an alarming rate in the Vietnam War. To address this, they created the Top Gun program, an intensive training school designed to sharpen pilots' combat skills. The program focused on providing pilots with extensive flight time and realistic combat simulations. This volume of experience, coupled with rigorous debriefings and performance analysis, created a powerful feedback loop. Pilots learned from their mistakes, adapted their tactics, and significantly improved their combat effectiveness. (Michel, 2011) Top Gun condensed this learning cycle. Pilots flew frequently, received immediate feedback, and applied those lessons in the next training session, accelerating their skill development.

SpaceX focused on solving the right problem and enabling the entire team to learn and fail fast.

Elon Musk, the visionary behind SpaceX, has revolutionized space travel with his relentless pursuit of innovation. Central to his approach is a focus on rapid iteration and feedback. Musk's engineering philosophy emphasizes simplifying, optimizing, and accelerating cycle times. This allows SpaceX to produce and launch rockets at a high rate, generating valuable data with each mission. Every launch, whether successful or not, provides a wealth of information that feeds back into the design process. This "feedback loop" enables SpaceX to improve its rockets continuously, pushing the boundaries of space exploration. As Musk himself has said, "A high production rate solves many ills." (Musk, 2018) But it's not just the high production rate; it's the speed at which SpaceX can incorporate learnings and launch again that truly sets them apart. They relentlessly compress the time between iterations, accelerating the learning process.

These examples illustrate a fundamental principle: progress is driven by experience and the ability to learn from it rapidly. Whether designing weapons, engaging in aerial combat, or launching rockets, the combination of real-world testing, feedback, and short cycle times accelerates improvement.

The power of real-world testing and rapid iteration are not novel and yet application of the principles can evoke fear. 

While the examples of the Gatling gun, Top Gun, and SpaceX illustrate the power of volume and feedback, this concept is neither new nor obscure. History is replete with inventors, artists, and entrepreneurs who achieved breakthroughs through relentless experimentation and learning. Thomas Edison famously asserted, "I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work," highlighting his commitment to iterative progress. So why, then, do so many individuals and organizations struggle to embrace this approach? The answer lies in the emotional challenge of committing to a process that inherently involves setbacks and failures. Psychologically, humans tend to avoid situations that could lead to negative emotions like disappointment or shame. This aversion to failure can stifle experimentation and prevent us from persisting long enough to see results. 

Our society often glorifies overnight success, obscuring the years of dedicated effort and iterative learning that underlie most achievements. This creates unrealistic expectations and can lead to disillusionment when progress is not immediate. Overcoming these emotional hurdles requires cultivating a growth mindset, embracing failure as a learning opportunity, and maintaining a long-term perspective.

A culture enabled and equipped to rapidly iterate through experimentation and feedback can achieve breakthrough results    

1. Foster a growth mindset

Companies need to foster an environment where experimentation is encouraged, and failure is seen as a learning opportunity. This means empowering employees to test new ideas, take calculated risks, and iterate quickly. Fostering a growth mindset involves shifting focus from innate talent to the power of effort and learning (Dweck, 2006). As Carol Dweck, a pioneer in growth mindset research, emphasizes, it's about believing that abilities can be developed through dedication and hard work (Dweck, 2006).  

Amazon's Jeff Bezos famously said, "If you're not failing, you're not experimenting enough." This mindset allows companies to explore new possibilities and discover innovative solutions.

2. Embrace failure as a learning opportunity

Embracing failure as a learning opportunity requires a conscious shift in perspective. Instead of viewing setbacks as personal inadequacies, one should analyze them for actionable insights. As Carol Dweck explains in "Mindset: The New Psychology of Success," a growth mindset sees failures as opportunities for improvement, not as fixed limitations (Dweck, 2006). This involves actively seeking feedback, reflecting on mistakes, and adjusting strategies accordingly, which fosters resilience and promotes continuous learning.

3. Shorten feedback loops

To master the art of volume and feedback, businesses can leverage the OODA loop, a concept developed by Colonel John Boyd, a fighter pilot and military strategist. The OODA loop stands for Observe, Orient, Decide, Act. It describes a continuous cycle of learning and adaptation that allows individuals and organizations to gain an advantage in dynamic environments. (Boyd, 1987)

• Observe: Gather information from the environment, including customer feedback, market trends, and competitor actions.

• Orient: Analyze the information, understand its implications, and challenge existing assumptions.

• Decide: Make informed decisions based on the available information.

• Act: Implement decisions quickly and decisively.

By shortening their OODA loop, businesses can respond more effectively to changes in the market and outmaneuver their competitors. This requires a commitment to rapid iteration, data-driven decision-making, and a culture that embraces change. The faster a company can cycle through the OODA loop, the more agile and responsive it becomes.

4. Maintain a long-term perspective

Maintaining a long-term perspective while rapidly iterating requires balancing immediate feedback with strategic vision. Companies should establish clear, overarching goals that act as a compass, guiding short-term iterations. As Clayton M. Christensen emphasized in "The Innovator's Dilemma," disruptive innovation often involves short-term setbacks that ultimately contribute to long-term success (Christensen, 1997). Therefore, feedback should be analyzed through the lens of those long-term goals, ensuring that rapid iterations serve the broader vision and avoid chasing fleeting trends.

The most sustainable competitive advantage is the ability to learn and evolve faster than anyone else

To truly harness the transformative power of volume and feedback, organizations must transcend mere theoretical understanding and embed these principles into their operational DNA. This means fostering a culture where experimentation is not just tolerated, but celebrated; where failure is not a stigma, but a stepping stone; and where the relentless pursuit of data-driven insights fuels every decision. Beyond the mechanics of shortened feedback loops and agile methodologies, the crucial shift lies in cultivating a collective mindset that embraces continuous learning and adaptation. By empowering individuals to challenge assumptions, iterate rapidly, and learn from every outcome, organizations can unlock a dynamic engine of innovation, mirroring the historical breakthroughs achieved by those who dared to embrace the iterative process. Only then can they consistently achieve the kind of breakthrough results showcased by the Gatling gun, Top Gun, and SpaceX, proving that the most sustainable competitive advantage is the ability to learn and evolve faster than anyone else.

About Us: We transform the world by serving firms of influence. We unlock the potential of those who advance the world.

• We bring perspective and insights to the world’s toughest problems

• We drive impact by considering and weighing material factors in a decision

• We emphasize your unique sources of competitive advantage

• We lead with brevity and candor

• We take our identity entirely from the success of our clients

​

We apply our advanced understanding of human behavior and our deep experience applying disruptive technologies to solve the world’s most pressing problems.

Interested in learning more about our capabilities or discussing your story? We’re here to help.